When planning a kitchen renovation, one of the biggest choices you’ll face is deciding between modular kitchen cabinets and custom kitchen cabinetry. Cabinets typically account for about 40 to 50 percent of the total cost of kitchen renovation, so choosing the right type is crucial for your design, timeline, and wallet.
At renoWOW!, we’ve helped countless Toronto homeowners find the best solution for their space—whether that means high-end custom cabinetry or a smart blend of modular and custom elements. In this guide, we break down the key differences to help you choose what’s right for your kitchen and your budget.
What Are Modular and Custom Cabinets?
Let’s start with a clear understanding of what each option brings to the table.
Modular Cabinets
These are also known as stock cabinets. They’re pre-manufactured in standard sizes and configurations, which makes them easy to source and quick to install. Because they’re mass-produced, they’re also more budget-friendly. If you’re focused on speed and cost savings, modular cabinets can be a great fit.
Custom Cabinets
With custom kitchen cabinetry, everything is built to suit your exact space. From cabinet dimensions to door styles, colours, and internal storage features, it’s all tailored to your preferences. Custom cabinets are handcrafted using premium materials and allow for total design freedom, making them ideal for unique layouts or specific style goals.
Semi-Custom Cabinets
There’s also a middle ground. Semi-custom cabinets start with modular units but allow you to make limited adjustments, such as resizing, choosing different finishes, or upgrading materials. This hybrid approach can offer the flexibility you want without going fully custom.
Also Read: Benefits of Open Shelving vs. Closed Cabinets in Kitchens
Cost Comparison Breakdown
Cost is often the deciding factor for many homeowners, especially when working with a set kitchen remodelling budget. Here’s a rough estimate of what you can expect to spend in Canada:
| Cabinet Type | Estimated Cost per Linear Foot |
| Modular | $80-$350 |
| Semi-Custom | $250-$600 |
| Custom | $500-$1200+ |
These price ranges typically include base and upper cabinets, standard cabinet materials and finishes, and hardware. What’s not always included are the extra costs for shipping, professional kitchen cabinet installation, design consultations, and any upgrades like soft-close hinges or specialty drawers.
If you’re looking for ways to stretch your dollar without compromising quality, check out our guide on 8 Money-Saving Tips for a Smart Kitchen Remodel.
Design & Aesthetic Flexibility
Your cabinets set the tone for your entire kitchen, so it’s important to think about how much design flexibility you really need.
Modular Cabinets
With modular cabinets, your options are more limited. They come in a fixed range of sizes and styles, making it difficult to fully customize your layout or match a very specific aesthetic. Colour and finish options are usually basic, and internal storage features may be minimal.
Custom Cabinets
Custom kitchen cabinetry gives you complete control over design. Want ceiling-height cabinets with built-in lighting? Prefer a certain type of wood or finish? Need to work around an awkward corner? Custom lets you do all of that. You can also choose from high-end cabinet materials and finishes that aren’t typically available with stock options.
What’s great is that renoWOW! can help you mix and match—combining modular base units with custom uppers to strike the perfect balance between cost and creativity.
Installation Timeline & Process
Another factor to consider is how long it will take to get your cabinets installed. Here’s a general timeline:
| Cabinet Type | Lead Time | Installation Notes |
| Modular | 1-2 weeks | Ready to go if in stock. Quicker install for simple layouts |
| Custom | 6-10 weeks | Requires detailed measurements, design review, and expert installation |
| Semi-Custom | 3-6 weeks | Offers some flexibility with shorter wait times |
A handy homeowner or contractor can often install modular cabinets, but custom cabinetry in Toronto typically needs professional support to ensure the fit and finish are just right. The team at renoWOW! manages everything from measurements to final installation, so there are no surprises.
Durability & Long-Term Value
Quality materials and construction methods greatly affect how your cabinets perform over time.
Modular Cabinets
These are often made from MDF or particleboard. While they’re fine for light to moderate use, they may start to show wear and tear within 10 to 15 years, especially in busy households.
Custom Cabinets
Custom units are typically built from higher-quality materials like plywood or solid wood. With proper care, they can last 25 years or more. You’ll also find better craftsmanship, such as dovetail joinery, soft-close hinges, and full-extension drawer glides—all of which contribute to a better user experience and longer lifespan.
To make the most of your investment, see our tips in Maximizing Kitchen Space: Smart Storage Solutions.
Resale Value & ROI
If you’re renovating with resale in mind, the type of cabinets you choose can influence your return on investment.
- Modular cabinets typically provide an ROI of about 60 to 70 percent, especially when paired with other upgrades like new countertops or appliances.
- Custom cabinetry often delivers a higher ROI, around 75 to 85 percent, especially if your design is timeless and the craftsmanship stands out.
Buyers notice quality kitchens. Investing in custom cabinets can be particularly worthwhile if you plan to stay in your home long-term or target a higher-end market.
What’s Right for You? Scenarios
Still not sure which option fits your needs? Let’s look at a few common renovation goals:
Budget Kitchen Reno
Modular cabinets from a reputable source paired with professional installation can give you a beautiful result without stretching your budget too far.
Forever Home
If this is your dream kitchen in your forever home, custom cabinetry makes sense. It allows you to tailor every detail to your lifestyle and aesthetic.
Tight Space or Odd Layout
Do you have a tricky kitchen layout with unusual angles or limited space? Custom is usually the way to go. You’ll avoid awkward fillers and make the most of every square inch.
renoWOW! Pro Tip Section
Looking for ways to elevate your kitchen while keeping an eye on the bottom line? Here are some helpful tips from our experts:
- Combine modular base cabinets with custom uppers for a unique yet budget-friendly design.
- Opt for sustainable options like FSC-certified wood or low-VOC finishes if eco-consciousness is important to you.
- Don’t overlook the details—cabinet materials and finishes are just the beginning. Soft-close hinges, pull-out trays, and drawer organizers can transform the way you use your kitchen.
Let renoWOW! Help You Make the Right Choice
Whether you’re leaning toward the speed and simplicity of modular kitchen cabinets or the craftsmanship and flexibility of custom kitchen cabinetry, your choice will shape the heart of your home for years to come.
Still wondering which option is best for your kitchen? Talk to our team for a free consultation and explore how we can bring your vision to life. If you’re looking for Local Kitchen Renovation Contractors you can trust, renoWOW! is ready when you are.
The team at renoWOW! has decades of experience helping homeowners across Toronto and the GTA make the right cabinetry decisions. We understand how to balance form, function, and funds—and we’re here to guide you every step of the way.
